Borg’s Blog

Resistance is futile – change is constant

  •  

    August 2009
    M T W T F S S
    « Mar    
     12
    3456789
    10111213141516
    17181920212223
    24252627282930
    31  
  • Meta

Google documents: a better alternative

Posted by Mark Winegar on 28th September 2008

Microsoft has dominated the software industry since the early 1980’s and made Bill Gates one of the richest men in the world but it’s days in the sun may be numbered?

Like many educators I returned to school this year to find Microsoft Office 2007 installed on the computers my students were issued. The latest version of Office looks and feels very different from its predecessors without adding any obvious new features of value. I find it less intuitive and more difficult to work with. My situation was not good.

My first challenge was to get Office 2007 installed on my computer so I could do demonstrations in a general education course on computing. Faculty computers were not scheduled to be updated. Yes someone was asleep at the wheel! Assertiveness paid off though and I met my class the next morning with the poorly designed upgrade. However, my long-term dissatisfaction with the school’s lack of software revision management was joined by a growing dissatisfaction in Office 2007.

I often wonder why Microsoft insists on making software for the masses that is too complicated for the common man to use? There lies it’s Achilles’ heel.

Google has, I believe, a better alternative. Google Documents freely provides the basic functions of word processing, spreadsheets, and presentation graphics to everyone on the Web. Their solutions are Web applications you can run on any computer connected to the Internet. They simply run in your web browser.

Here’s a dirty little industry secret. The vast majority of users only use about 10% of the functionality of Microsoft Word, Excel, and PowerPoint. The remaining features are there for a vocal minority of power users who rarely use them anyway. So why complicate matters by including features most of us will never use? Intimidation?

Google’s software focuses on the sweet spots of functionality where the vast majority of people get their work done. The menus are sleeker and intuitive. You can easily find what you need to do and the software works more efficiently because the code is simpler. Simpler code means fewer software failures!

This is a good deal! You can get your work done without making Bill Gates any richer. Did I forget to mention you can work with files in Microsoft formats too. This means your work is compatible with all the poor suckers still running Microsoft Office!

The best part of Google Documents is the new features they got right!

First, your files are always safe because they are stored on Google’s servers which means you can access them anywhere you can connect to the Web. So you don’t have to carry the luggable laptop around the airport anymore! More importantly though is the fact your files are regularly backed up and kept safe by professional system administrators.

Second, you can actually collaborate on project files with no version control issues! I was blown away when I tested this feature.

The following podcast will show you how to get started using Google Documents.

It seems Google is leaving Microsoft in its software engineering dust!

Posted in reviews | No Comments »

Using the buddy system

Posted by Mark Winegar on 22nd August 2008

Do you remember those hot summer days at camp? Can you still feel the cold water hitting your skin as you dove head first into the lake? Do you remember your swimming counselor’s cardinal rule? Yes, stay with your buddy.

Every year thousands of freshman dive into the cold waters of higher education. It feels good. They are beginning to experience new degrees of freedom but far too often they miss the fact they also have new degrees of responsibility. Mom and Dad aren’t there to check on their homework so they have to learn to manage their own time. Unfortunately many fail.

I think creating an academic buddy system may be a productive way to reinforce positive behaviors in college and better prepare students for a modern world of work. I personally cannot create a buddy system for the entire freshman experience but I can do so for my general education class. Success can be assessed by analyzing student comments about their impressions of the buddy system.

My general education course introduces freshman to the use of Microsoft Office and the Modern Language Association’s style guide. The course goals are to equip them with the software skills necessary for success as undergraduate students. Focus is placed on Microsoft Outlook, Word, Excel, and PowerPoint. The skills are important but Microsoft offers weak support for collaborative activity. What is really needed is something that enables students to closely collaborate with their buddies. Google docs offers an interesting alternative.

Google is all about collaboration. It provides a free email system called Gmail which serves as a jump off point to a variety of digital activities. Gmail can gather email from multiple accounts in one place so my students ought to be able to receive email from their college accounts there. It provides a convenient calendar to support time management and students can personalize their home pages with graphic themes and RSS feeds to their favorite blogs. These home pages provide a direct link to Google docs.

The key concept of Google docs is to provide a virtual work space where collaborators can work on word processing documents, spreadsheets, and presentations in real time without regard of space or time. Files are stored on Google’s servers so they can be accessed anywhere you find a computer connected to the World Wide Web. Files are secure because access is password protected and routine backups are performed. Google docs are Microsoft compatible too!

Is Google docs an appropriate software suite to teach? Many major corporations and research universities have turned to Google docs over Microsoft Office because of the advantages it offers so it is a viable alternative. The skills learned in my course are word processing, spreadsheets, and presentation graphics. These skills are universal amongst alternative productivity software suites so there isn’t an issue of drastically changing the content of the course. The strategic advantage is offers is its rich support of collaborative activity.

I’ve visited with a few of my peers about this and they said “Go for it!” so I am diving in head first with Google as my buddy. Keep tuned in to see how it goes.

Posted in CIS125 - Basic IT Skills | No Comments »

Caveat emptor

Posted by Mark Winegar on 15th July 2008

For the uninitiated this means “buyer beware!

The buzz of the summer is Microsoft’s brand new operating system Vista. I couldn’t think of a more appropriate statement concerning it than caveat emptor. 

If you are the IT guru at an institution of higher learning run as far away from Vista as you can. And fast! New versions of Microsoft’s Windows operating system are like the sexy new cars our fathers warned us about. They were full of promises and looked great but they were all full of problems. Dad always said “wait a couple of years until they shake all the bugs out!” And he was right!

There have been lots of stories about all of the devices that stop working when you install Vista. They may be true. I don’t know. I do know that you want your students and faculty to come to a fully functioning campus. So, sit this one out for awhile and watch the agony of others.

If you really have to make a change junk out all of your PCs and replace them with Macs. Trust me on this. You won’t regret it.

Posted in reviews | No Comments »